The sociology of Paul the Octopus : Sports : Avijit Ghosh : TOI Blogs
You are here: Home Blogs Sports

ADDICTIONS

The sociology of Paul the Octopus

Avijit Ghosh
13 July 2010, 03:08 PM IST

Thomas Muller has received the Golden Boot and Diego Forlan has earned the Golden Ball. But it's undeniable that Paul the Octopus was the real star of the 2010 football World Cup. No living creature was as much loved and lampooned as the invertebrate from Germany. The buzz he generated was greater than the vuvuzelas.
 
His retirement from making further predictions was announced on Monday. The move is rather well timed. On the face of it, it sounds like a decent voluntary retirement scheme (VRS): Paul will just play with his handlers and delight the kids from now on. Those running the show on behalf of Paul knew that the game had gone too far. It was only a matter of time before the law of averages caught up with the octopus's prescience. The perceptive move by the Sea Life Aquarium authorities will ease Paul into pop culture mythology. Whenever the 2010 World Cup is discussed or written about, he will find more than a mention.
 
The interesting sociological question, though, is: why did we fall for Paul? Most of us were keen to engage with his predictions rather than dismiss them as fluke. We all know that an octopus understands as much football as Yuvraj Singh reads Chinese literature. We also know that if two flags from the same country were placed on the boxes, Paul would have still gone for the mussels. Sure eight out of eight is an extraordinary run of luck. But that doesn't make him a tentacled tipster with psychic powers. Paul the Octopus is just a creature with a hunger for good seafood.
 
Perhaps the reason for Paul's incredible popularity is that he brought a degree of levity to the serious business of football. In a sense, he was to the 2010 World Cup football championship what cheerleaders are to the IPL: the element of fun. Only, he is better looking and less energetic.
 
But more than that, he rescued football from the clutches of the pundits and handed it over to the common people. Pundits make us aware about our inadequacies. Paul countered that by becoming the perfect astrologer. Paul stood in for them. His choice became the voice of everybody who didn't have a reason to choose. In his success, millions saw themselves, and consequently rejoiced. During any major sporting event, a large section disinterested in sports is left out of the discourse. Paul gave them a toehold. He was almost the half-brother of Larissa Riquelme, the Paraguayan model who perked up a million lives across the globe. Here was something, beyond those stupid free kicks, everybody could discuss.
 
For many, the octopus worked psychologically at another level. Football is also an article of faith. To them, the octopus reaffirmed what they believed in; he became the voice they wanted to hear. Those on the wrong side of his picking got mad. To them, Paul became like one of those evil medieval witches who could unerringly foresee doom. Either way, he became a talking point.
 
It's unlikely that we will see Paul in action again. That's unless we take the trouble to visit his residence at the Sea Life Aquarium in Oberhausen town. But perhaps as an idea, Paul will continue to be among us. Just wait for the cricket World Cup 2011. We will have plenty of desi versions of Paul as breaking news.

23 Comments |  Comments are closed. Rated
 
 
 

Comments:

Sort by: Oldest | Newest | Recommended (23) | Most Discussed


Amit Deshpande says:

July 13,2010 at 03:53 PM IST

Even a Firangi Octopus gets attention. If Paul was to be believed, then what was wrong with our own desi Popatlal who used to choose cards for us?
Check this image, Paul liked Yellow colour more

(Reply to Amit Deshpande)- Ziauddin Shafi says:

July 15,2010 at 01:38 PM IST

Gambling is legal in most of the soccer-playing countries of the west. Paul helped punters with his choices that worked as an extra tip to those playing with their money - such is the frailty of these hard-nosed punters. And of course it distracted from the electric and tense atmosphere - sort of a comic relief.

 

Shabha says:

July 13,2010 at 04:12 PM IST

If we are addicted to predictions, we may pray for long life of Paul to live till next WC in Brazil. Average age of octopus is four to five years. But the male dies about a month after mating. In other case, Paul's off spring can be assigned the job of predictions. For reasons of economy the trend should continue.

 

unemployedsociologist says:

July 13,2010 at 06:01 PM IST

Modi has kept the scribes busy. Paul keeps the sociologists in gainful occupation!

 

Ashok Gupta says:

July 13,2010 at 09:29 PM IST

How about recommending 'Paul the Octopus''s name for Nobel Peace Prize?

 

Bacon says:

July 13,2010 at 10:06 PM IST

One of the worst analogies I have read, "We all know that an octopus understands as much football as Yuvraj Singh reads Chinese literature." You could have done better on that one. I agree with you where you say that we will have plenty of desi versions of Paul during World Cup 2011. It's India. It's bound to happen. On an entirely different note, I am surprised to see Paul the Octopus getting so much coverage on TOI website and there's no mention of any person / organization who is helping out people or doing good out there. Think about it.

(Reply to Bacon)- Joemike says:

July 14,2010 at 11:56 PM IST

Dear BACON, You seems to read only what you want. Have you not read on TOI recently that Sachin Tendulkar, appealed for charity cause and got a huge response. And that Mr. Sunil Mittal is sponsoring 550 schools in India. etc etc. Wake up from your dream.

 

karan says:

July 13,2010 at 11:03 PM IST

It is just amazing to see so many armchair so called experts are writing about the football world cup in a nation of virtually no sports, including football. To begin with there are no football fields in any school in the entire country, barring may be few exceptions. If you read the Indian newspapers and watch the gossip TV channels you would think that India is a football power house with no comparison in the world. You will never see such insanity anywhere in the world. I have not seen such coverage of football in Europe or even in Brazil. India has become the epicenter of falsification of everything including passion of sport!

 

krishnaswami says:

July 14,2010 at 01:05 AM IST

Paul also gave a non-entity like you a chance to write about sport. He gave you an opportunity to write about the beautiful game and allowed you to earn your salary.

 

KALKI says:

July 14,2010 at 09:32 AM IST

I am really fed up with this Paul article after article. All the writers are either scared to accept the proven fact that "there is truth beyond your simple brains" and billions of generations have passed on this earth before you.. Just because science has become predominant in life "thanks to the WEST", our fools too dont ever realise that everything we see, touch and feel is not anywhere close to outer realities and beyond time & space. The biggest joke is that being Foolish they consider themselves highly intelligent.. hmmm spain vs spain ?? Avit Gosh you realy look very smart mate.... Please try to read many more books and get into history & metaphysics and also the proven dailies where our great seers have told many things before hand

(Reply to KALKI)- LINEESHKU says:

July 14,2010 at 07:27 PM IST

who r u my lord? the great KALKI AVTAR?

(Reply to KALKI)- gin says:

July 17,2010 at 03:30 AM IST

sorry to disappoint you Kalki, but poor Paul is no guru of metaphysics or soothsaying bullshit. Statistics, of course, can explain the probabilities of his predictions.

 

Joy says:

July 14,2010 at 09:41 AM IST

Well Avijitda..call it mystique.... being agnostic or prejudiced....defy science or a mere coincidence ...who knows.. but fact of the matter is Paul remains the protagonist in this soccer world cup ! Sad to know you have gone back to your shell ..would dearly miss ya :))

 

KKK says:

July 14,2010 at 11:15 AM IST

Paul was also popular because he made a mockery of the professional tipsters and astrologers ---all those big names, beaten by an octopus....

 

yash says:

July 14,2010 at 11:33 AM IST

bad

 

Harsh says:

July 14,2010 at 01:04 PM IST

Well Avijitda..call it mystique.... being agnostic or prejudiced....defy science or a mere coincidence ...who knows.. but fact of the matter is Paul remains the protagonist in this soccer world cup ! Sad to know you have gone back to your shell ..would dearly miss ya :))

 

Harsh says:

July 14,2010 at 01:05 PM IST

One of the worst analogies I have read, "We all know that an octopus understands as much football as Yuvraj Singh reads Chinese literature." You could have done better on that one. I agree with you where you say that we will have plenty of desi versions of Paul during World Cup 2011. It's India. It's bound to happen. On an entirely different note, I am surprised to see Paul the Octopus getting so much coverage on TOI website and there's no mention of any person / organization who is helping out people or doing good out there. Think about it.

 

Divya says:

July 14,2010 at 04:28 PM IST

Nice article sir:)

 

Golden Eagle says:

July 14,2010 at 06:32 PM IST

Wow! I thought it was all over and done with. But while a few dumbos like you still find it worth writing about it, other dumbs like me will keep on reading. Lets stop this nonsense. Write something meaningful and useful.

 

Monty says:

July 14,2010 at 07:09 PM IST

If we start believing in these supestitions, then whats the need for anybody to get so much education??!! Also, there wouldnt be any need to play soccer at all....just ask Paul whos gonna win the world cup and hand over the trophy to them!!

 

Indranil says:

July 14,2010 at 11:49 PM IST

Most imp takeaway... your tunnel vision bias against cheerleaders! Some of them were lovely, extremely fit and healthy young ladies, who were doing their jobs - entertaining crowds through well choreographed dance routines! Just because WE dont want to offer them a certificate of moral conduct because WE have convenient definitions of what is moral and what is not, doesn't mean we have the right to criticize one's livelihood, irrespective of the IQ/EQ/whatever Q of a person! Reeks of bias...

Of course Paul is the topic of discussions here, but I think enough has been said about him already, without me trying to wax eloquence or rile at him!

 

abhay says:

July 15,2010 at 01:31 AM IST

I don't believe in such things , its all about game& team work. if they play good , they will win ....its a simple logic.if you follow the soccer you will come to know the Sapin is the number one choice by soccer analyst

 

Kanu Mistry says:

July 15,2010 at 01:45 PM IST

It is a sensible decision by German authorities to stop any more predictions by the Octopus. This is the way it should be. There is a limit to encourage any kind of superstition and the Germans have learnt it well in time. Our media and journalists should learn from this.

 

Comments on this Post are now closed.

Top Rated

More
  • Day
  • |
  • Week
  • |
  • Month
  • |
  • Year

Archives
« September 2010
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
   
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
  
       
Today
 
SEARCH TIMES BLOGS
 
 
ABOUT AVIJIT GHOSH More
Avijit Ghosh works as a senior assistant editor at The Times of India in Delhi. Born in Agartala, he grew up in different small towns of Bihar and Jharkhand. He is addicted to films, music, cricket and football. He has written two books: "Bandicoots in the Moonlight", a novel, and "Cinema Bhojpuri", a book on films.
 
The views expressed in Addictions are the author´s own.
 
 
Powered by Indiatimes