...And I think to myself,
What a wonderful world.

Are you right.
The compensation should be four cents as hidden slides would show the distribution procedure and expenditure incurred on the cases and handling charges etc to be compensated from the compensating amount. Time frame of awarding compensation should also not be fixed, let it drag on,on..
The drafting of bills normally leaves loopholes to be exploited later by concerned parties. These loopholes may be pro powerful and anti poor.
Clever copanies will manage to contest even four cent compensation on the plea that it is uneconomical to distribute and may be exempted..

A single nuclear accident is not going to kill all of India's 1.1 billion people. Nuclear reactors are usually situated in isolated areas away from large cities, so civilian casualties would be down to a minimum. I'm sure there are exceptions, but any new reactors that come up will likely be at a safe distance. I don't agree with the cap on liabilities in the event of an accident, but I don't think it's justifiable to assume that a single nuclear accident would wipe out all of India's 1.1 billion population.

Why do you have to divide the total amount by 1.1 Bn people. There needs to be a cap so that different companies can evaluate the risk and operate in India. $450Mn is for the area affected, for example if we implement it for Bhopal then this amount us for people who got affected during the Bhopal gas tragedy not for whole of India. So please reconsider before making big statements.

the government of india whether now or before has always cheated the indian people ever since 1990. We have become so used to the follies and cheating that we pay no heeds and hounds to the working of overnment. we have just become the arm chair critics who yell at others but never try to do something for the cause. So whatever is happening i think its just the interest of the mistakes that we as citizens of india have commited. This will continue to happen untill we overcome our Alzheimer's symptoms and repaying bck what the politicians have done to the countrymen so long.

Why work for an MNC? Many Indians are already discovering for themselves that there is much more to be made than 40 cents, when they work directly for overseas clients, using the Internet.

Your math is funny. Why divide $450 million by the entire population of India? Unless of course you are assuming that one nuclear accident will affect the entire population of India, which is utterly impossible.

On a more important note, it is not just the MNCs think Indian lives are cheap, the Indian government thinks so as well. How else do you explain such miserable statistics as these:
1) 47% of all Indian children under the age of six are malnourished and stunted.
2) Each year, 2.5 million Indian children die before reaching the age of three.
3) 41% of Indians live below the International Absolute Poverty Line.
4) 400 million Indians do not have access to electricity.
5) Diarrhea kills 1000 children EVERY DAY.
6) Functional literacy rate stands at barely more than 50%.
7) 160 million Untouchables remain oppressed and shunned and lead a sub-human existence.

Let's admit it, the Indian lives are cheap, since their own government is treating them like the cheapest of all commodities. Sad, but true.

How did this happen in a democracy?

The contention conveyed in this article is quite distorted. Any calamity of any nature will not affect all the 1.1 billion Indians. In fact, the author himself claims that some relations of the victim will remain alive to claim the compensation of 40 cents. I am sure, there many more like the author, who wait for an opportunity to oppose. Industrial accidents do taken place, not only in India but in every country in the world. May be Bhopal Gas tragety was a very big tragedy for the country, but that does not mean that no similar industry should be permitted. Let us remember that thousands of people die in the country through electric shock, does it mean that we should stop producing electricity. Many more people die because of road accidents, should we stop all the vehicles. Let us remember that India is one amongst very few countries (both developed and developing countries included) which have never been able to meet its power requirements. So let us not support all these meaningless hurdles. For once, let our common man enjoy the benefits of uninterrupted power supply.

Indians themselves dont value human life, how can they expect MNCs to show any value. Look at desi IT companies, they are supposed to be run by more educated Indians, they also dont treat Indian employees with respect.

Our culture itself has to improve in terms of how a living and dead human being is to be treated.

Compensation is still a far off thing, my dad has to pay the babu for getting his pension increments all the time. He served the govt as officer for 36 years to deserve the pension. If he is so helpless infront of the system, I doubt how others would be managing their day to day life.

The Bhopal gas tragedy would have made some of the Indian ministers multi millionaires and all the money would have been deposited in Switzerland or other secret banks outside India. As truly rated, India is the most corrupt land in the world ruled by the most corrupt people. Sonia Gandhi says she does not own a car and have only few lakhs in banks, She does not clarify how much in secret banks outside India. It has been revealed that $1.4 trillion of Indian money are deposited in foreign secret banks, I am sure the actual amount is triple of that.

Only God can save my country.

Then why don't u publish this in all the regional languages so that it reaches the masses who can at least get up, unite and revolt. If the govt' is treating its citizens like rotten eggs then what is the use of such a treaty.....Bhopal disaster is still simmering, people are actually abondoned without any help what so ever!

Jago re India

Mr Shobhan, It was really nice to read your points respecting the value of Indian life. But I doubt govt will read your column and do anything?
I wish these good columns would fetch some modifications in the ugly rule that says "There's no cap on profit these MNCs can make in this poor country, but there's a cap on compensation". As a result, there is no cap on the amount of hate these MNCs would be receiving from Indian public.

This is a ridiculous argument dividing the compensation by the entire population as if entire india will die from a potential accident.

Its a wonderful article and must be published nationally so that every one becomes aware of their value in the hands of these MNC's.Bhopal tragedy has its adverse aftermaths and not defyinf this bill and raiisng voice agianst the bill ,we are sure to head into another such tragedy with no remedy.So we the people of INDIA have to stand up for ourself, our nation.

For all those saying that he shouldn't divide 450000000 by 1.1 billion, maybbe you're right, but divide it by 500000, which is the number of people killed by the bhopal gas tragedy, then you get 900. This is INR 41,908.27. Are you kidding me? Is this what is to be given to victims of such a disaster?

This is just the beginning of pushing India towards further poverty. First it was the British (Gore), now its Congress under the guidance (influence of) Sonia Gandhi another (Gori), who are eating away India's wealth.
In my another comment I wrote our leaders have not changed, during British rule our leaders were second rate leaders, today they are still second rate leaders, spineless.
They must have made millions for themselves in this deal. On the second thought, their European mistress must have ordered them to present this bill and our spineless leaders must have been licking her soles.

And all this only because a man called Manmohan Singh wanted to secure his next 5 years as PM (vs Yuvaraj Rahul Gandhi). US and MNCs know that Manmohan Singh can be very easily manipulated because he wants to push n-deal at any cost during his tenure because he has made it his prestige issue. If a few million Indians die here and there how does it matter to him?

with the newly acquired outlook .. i think i better get a heaftier LIFE INSURANCE done.. lol !!

Thank and appreciate the perspective shown by Shobhan ..

Contents of this article and its argument is well taken and deserves to be taken very seriously.

While Govt may have tabled a proposal....question is what we as citizen value each other. Is it not the way we set precedents and social justice in a democracy?

What value have we palced on ourselves each one of us. The smallest and yet vital and strongest institution in any given society is FAMILY We have reneged our social responsibilities and as a people not set the standards in society and therefore democratically given the rights to others to set a value for ourselves

Social Justice...Good Social Policies....Valued social programs is the best public education we can instill so our parents men and women of all ages children and future generations realize our true value not only material....humanity....human rights....and citizenship

Really,
I'm still confuse that our why governments are supporting all these MNC, Is there mean like we don't have values of our life in front of these MNC or is there any other matter..!!!???

Just a simple and genuine request to our government "please value our self, we are not just a 40 cents people!!!"

Hats off to you for such a useful information.
NETAS are saying about to generate patriotism in every indian, but why should people love their country, if they are loving their country than too do government love them??
If yes than 40 Cents....is it a really worthy amount??
Govt. should propose them for no accident and if accident occurs they cant operate their business deals in any of the country.That company does not have rights to kill anybody.
If they are not sure about whether accident will occur or not better to not start the work.

Actually I agree with some of the views in here, the views that say that indian government does not care about the indian people. Although the idea of the article was to question the same it came out in a different light. The country needs to know the importance and sancticity of life. Today we see so many cases of killing and rape in India and that is because the government does not care. With such a government one cannot expect them to do anything good for the people. Look at the stupidity of our masses. We elect people who think of problems like having a state for a section of people and worry on those things when the basic amenities are not there. Electoral candidates spend millions in hotels when another part of the country is hit with starvation and flood. We the people have no business to comment on anything when we are the people who elect such idiots into our parliament. So suck it up and dont complain that is all I have to say because at the end of the day it is each individual who is writing this who made sure that their life is worth only this much.

The compensation amount $450 million may be acceptable by the parliament, because in a coalition government the maximum number of MPs in the government may be 300, plus 150 from the opposition who can be hired for passing the bill. So $ 1 million each for an MP is not bad in India. Then how can you offer 40 cents for me and you? Bhopal tragedy reveals that human beings are the cheapest commodity in the world. We have a system that always susceptible to Temple and Mosque syndrome. Netas and babus are least bothered about our basic problem like this. More than 15,000 people killed with many thousands suffering from blindness to cancer is not at all a case of shaking their conscience. Bhopal victims are no longer vote bank items. And our democratic spine is more flexible to prostrate before the multinationals and imperialism. We have a mark of wart on our neck as a result of having been the carrier of the yoke of imperialism since very long. So we still feel that invisible yoke and are susceptible to bow down to the West for everything they dictate
Whatever the ideas you preserve in the blog are not at all utopian in their real sense. But you dish out these to many of our Kumbhakarnas in the parliament house. Kumbhakarna, five years they eat the exchequer if they are in the government, and five years they sleep, if they are in the opposition. Recently somebody suggested we have to lead the Commonwealth. Why should we do that, when koda like people loot our common wealth? At present we ranked 84th in the corruption index. And the recent opinion poll of 83.4% seems to be authentic. If the situation goes like this, the Swiss coffers will be impregnated with our common wealth. We can wake those who are in slumber, but we cannot those who pretend to be asleep. That is the excruciating agony for the true citizens.

The anguish is understandable but to whom the blame is targeted is not clear. Who is inviting the MNCs, being well aware of their motive to make investment in India or any foreign country for that matter? Who is making the bargain and feels the pleasure to sign the contract document on the dotted line? Who feel the pleasure to celebrate the entry to the nuclear club? Who feel proud in claming growth of FDI figure? Who gets elated in writing sonorous editorials and edifying blogs on growing so called friendly relation with the largest super power in the present day world? The author of the article must be knowing that every thing has a price. There is no free lunch in this vale of tears.I don't remember who said "it is business stupid" or some thing like this; a prophetic utterance indeed.Be kind enough to give up pretension. Be "bold and beautiful".

Great observation but in case of an accident in India neighboring countries may just as well be effected so why not include their population also to make your point better --- like 0.01 cents taking entire south Asian population into consideration.

Excellent article. I didnt know about this till i read your article. Thanks for bringing it to our notice. Shame on Indian politicians who are selling us cheap to these MNCs..

It is a very lopsided analysis.Bad way of calculating numbers like a bad politican to highjack the agenda.If you are so worried about all the indians dying then why ask MNC's or foreign companies for their help/technical knowhow.You in your own capabilities are not able to do the job,want MNC's to help and pay you unlimited compensation in case of a mishap.What a nice way to ask help.Such a notion of fear of accident will not let us move anywhere.

The comments made by the writer are baseless and hypothetical.If ou country has to progress we have to open more and more doors of liberalisation.India is a countr of more than one billion people.To fullfill their daily needs we need to push nuclear deal.suppose as writter comments if their is accident and all Indians die then what is the use of 40 cent,who will get?this is useless predictions.

If the story is not just story then definitely it’s going to become an indefinite time bomb for all Indians. It a universal fact that the 123 agreement had lots of loophole and are open for exploitation. Its now in the hands of law maker and our great parliament to scrutinize new / amend laws for proper establishment of new power houses. Defining max limit of compensation before any accident will not help.

As Mr. Manish Chauhan said, there needs to be a cap so that different companies can evaluate the given risk and operate in India.
In this case, I have a feeling that, in all probability, the multi-national companies prevailed upon our govt. to agree to a cap because Indira Gandhi earlier reneged on the deal made with the Canadian Govt. that India would use their nuclear technology only for peaceful purposes and not to test a nuclear device (Pokhran).
Almost all contracts have a risk-limiting factor. Similarly, many successful companies limit their liabilities by registering themselves as "Limited Liability" companies. Without this option, we would have monopolies in business and trade where only the very cash-rich would venture into business. Also, there would be little growth, if companies are not able to hedge their risks.
Let us also be practical insomuch that we would also attempt to insulate ourselves from any risk, should we invest in any venture in another country.

kkk

The blogger has stated 40 cents is the cost of an Indian life for an American MNC. I may add that only the life of VVIPs matter in India. So many security guards are deployed to see to it that they are not killed and so many security arrangements are made for the same purpose. But what about the life of an average Indian? It is not even 40 cents. It is just nothing. 64% Indians just live a sub human existence. It is actually immaterial for anybody whether they live or die. While even the dust of the earth has some cost, the cost of these average Indians is just nothing. They live because they are born. That is all. Their deaths mean nothing more to the Government than the death of the dogs of the streets. Govt. announces compensations when media draw attention to some accidental deaths or deaths at the hands of the terrorists but these compensations are seldom paid.

If you are talking about the cost of nuclear power generation, I must say that the cost of not having nuclear power generation will be much higher than the cost of having nuclear power facilities. India has planned for a massive nuclear capacity addition primarily because the country understands that the growing demand for energy can not alone be met by conventional hydro carbon sources. Even the new and alternative sources will also not be able to contribute substantially. In this regard nuclear will need to be a key source of power generation. And now, if the author feels that all the nuclear power facilities that are going to be constructed will explode like a nuclear bomb I will not buy that argument.
The author could have talked a bit more in detail about nuclear insurance and how civil nuclear liability in other nuclear power countries are working now (do not tell me about space constraint). This would have certainly avoided the confusion. I would advise the readers to go through details on the same in WNA or IAEA sites.

But, if the author just wanted to mislead the readers and sensitize this...I am sure the article has done its job.

Today the main problem India's nuclear sector face is lack of sufficient awareness on this field. Despite this, none are bad at forming anti nuclear opinion, which is often capitalized by political sections.

JAGO INDIA JAGO..

First of all let me say that it is a nice article. Makes us aware of many things and raises questions on Government.
I would like to add some more details on nuclear plants being set up in different regions of our country.

Nuclear power plant being setup at in Maharashtra i.e. Jaitapur has many villeges near by. Many of the villegers are mango cultivators and some of them are fishermen. They are protesting the plant as it will definitely affect their business and might affect their lives in case of any mishap. Some of them are exporters of their cultivation and foreign businessmen are saying they won't accept their cultivation if there is nuclear power plant near by. So it is like, some one has to pay the price to get electric energy. I don't understand why that location was finalized. We have deserts in our country where our government can think about installing green energy sources like Solar power or Wind power instead of Nuclear power. Such setup would not cost any one else at least.

Another comment on the value of Indian Life. A few minutes back i read a news item stating that the Allahabad High Court has commuted the death sentence awarded to the killers of Manjnath, an IOC Sales Manager. Some one, who was caught adultrating the Petrol or Diesel, murders an aspiring management graduate at the prime age of 27 and he is found fit for relaxing the penalty awarded to him. And in all likely hood, he would be set free in the next stage of legal battle. Mr. Saxena, this is the live case where the intellectuals like you should fight for justice. But you have chosen to write on a matter which carries more ifs and buts than the entire storey. The case of Manjunath is indicative enough to establish that the life of an Indian is not even worth 40 Cents and ironically no MNC is involved in this case.

U know, even that 40cents wont be reached to people that will shared across by politician and finally may reach4 cents. We are living in this kind of country...

Notwithstanding the calculations and all the numbers and other arguments in favour/against, I am unable to understand the motivation for this law? Are the MNC companies that have to invest in nuclear technology in India saying they won't do it unless the GOI comes up with some law like this one to protect their liability? Also, were an India company to invest for exactly the same cause, is this law applicable to that company too? Or are we saying the Indian company will not ave this privilege or will be even more immune to their transgressions and failures to provide safety?

Shobhan - Like many out here - I dont agree with the math. But you do bring up an interesting point. If a nuclear plant were to be built in US and 450 mil is the cap on casualty the house ans the senate would have roared in laughter. if such a tragedy were to occur in US - even 1 mil per family is really low.
But sadly India is a thrid world country - the corrupt leaders are eyeing for kickback money ( think Enron). Any company setting up a power plant here would bring in huge money for their Swiss bank accounts. 450 mil is an attractive gimmick for getting them setup shop. We all profit from such venture- MNC get all the profit with low risk, political leaders get kickbacks and their reign continues and well about the people they get HOPE - one day we shall have electricity in our homes and villages.

Britishraj was better!!!!

Why is the Indian goverment limiting liability for a nuclear accident to 450 million dollars? If the liability was lifted to 2 billion dollars then all the nuclear operating companies need to do would be to take out insurance to cover the added liability.
The Indian goverment places little value on the lives of its citizens.
How much did the Chernobyl disaster cost and how much more is it going to cost?
Given the chalta hia attitude of Indians and their capacity to screw things up one would not want to live within 1000 kilometers from an Indian nuclear power plant

Reading this article it seems India is becoming day by day vulnerable to unpredictable calamities which may wreak havoc on a big scale.Before entering in to any such project first thing to be taken in to consideration is people`s welfare and if this is not seen then it is bad governance.

I was shocked, disturbed and frustrated after reading this blog. Shocked to know that the Indian government can do such a fraud to its own people. Disturbed to realise that that the world outside India doesn't know anything about this injustice. And frustrated by some comments which are more interested in nitpicking the math side of the argument. This article is the best I have read on any Indian website. Shobhan, with this blog, you have raised the bar for all Indian journalists and bloggers. Keep it up.

Hi, First off all why do we need to allow some one from out side of our country(US, Russia etc..) to establish Nuclear plants in India. I think anything related to energy should be under the control of government. Allowing some one else from outside of our country for establishing Nuke plants and allowing them to gain more profits and making government responsible for any accidents. First the government has to think before privatising such crucial and critical sectors. There should be an open public debate in this kind of issues. It's government responsibility to handle these kind of issues in more diligent and accountable way.

If we do not value our own life beleive me that no body will give a hoot to your life. We start from our own home. hav't you ever seen a whole family unit riding on a motor bike without halmet? You all must have seen this all over India. I proved my point that if you Indians do not value your life why should a foreigner should give a damm abouit it.

The writer wants to raise the concerns over the amount of compensation, I guess the debate is not on price of Indian citizen but the amount of compensation, I totally agree with the writer the amount is very less , it should be much higher, keeping in view of the distribution system ( not exist at all ), there is no clear disaster polices & guidelines. The most important part is that no transparency on the money utilized.Until and unless these things are fixed , govt set what ever amount , its as good as non existent. BIGGEST EXAMPLE IS BHOPAL.

I will want to leave aside the figures that is being reflected by your article and rather will want to concentrate upon the grave reality that we all are facing in the name of development, globalisation, etc.

It is truly inspirational when people like you write such educating and eye-opening articles. I think we should try to take your message to the masses and make them also realise of the situation around all of us.

Enjoyed reading it. Thank you so much :)

Shobhan, after reading this post, which was sent to me by a friend in Oxford, I read your other posts as well. Simply brilliant. Being an academic specialising on South Asia, it's wonderful to see an original and authentic voice emerging from India. I won't hesitate to call you Robert Fisk of India. Great writing and great opinions. I am looking forward to reading your next post.

#1: Liability shall rest with the Nuclear Power Corporation of India, not with the suppliers or contractors. It's NPC that will pay your 40 cents each out of GIC insurance, the suppliers won't pay (unless we sign the CSC, in which case they'll pay a little).
#2: Additional compensation - if required (and it very likely won't, since a real world 'nuclear disasters' using modern technology would typically involve the irradiation of site personnel, not the extinguishing of civilisations)- shall be paid from tax payers' money
#3 - Asking for corporate money for nuclear disasters is pointless because the cost of insurance shall make nuclear power hopelessly expensive on a per-unit-of-electricity basis.
#4 - In conclusion, if we want nuclear energy we have to live with the fact that compensation for a catastrophe will have to come from tax rupees.
#5 - The Bill is not unconstitutional and Supreme Court verdicts can and are overturned by legislative enactments - economic channeling of tort liability is a well-understood and frequently implemented concept, as is the capping of no-fault liability.

Cheers

A well-written article. MJ

Hey man!!! How can you forget reservations in India. SC/ST/OBC will get additional 20 cents and other will get only 20 cents.
I don't understand why SC/ST/OBC persons never come up and say that they do not need reservation and they wanto to face the challenge. It is really shame for SC/ST/OBC.

It's not really the point that India doesn't have the techinical knowhow to setup a nuke reactor. The point is that in case of an adverisity, if the MNCs who setup the nuclear reactor are at fault, they pay out enough compensation atleast for the rehabilitation of the affected population. We all remember Bhopal Gas disaster two decades ago. Union Carbide and now Dow Chemicals hasn't compensated enough to people of Bhopal for their misery. Union Carbide had a little mishap here in the U.S. and only 14 people were affected. Guess what the payout was in the US? The company was ordered to compensate around 1 billion dollars to be divided among 14 victims. I am not saying that the compensation amount should be so exorbitant that it repels any MNC to build a reactor in India. But Indian government is not getting its business right. American MNCs don't have much business in the U.S. They need to invest elsewhere. It's the same case with the French and the Russians. If there is competition then the question remains that why is the Indian government not taking advantage of it. In case of an accident, whoever is responsible should be made to take accountability and should be made to compensate for the mishap. If it is the operator who is found primararily responsible of not following operating procedures then the operator should be made to pay a resonable compensation to the victims. On the other hand, if a fault is found with the initial setup in the plant, then MNC should be held responsible and should be made to compensate for the full rehabilitation of victims and their families. Just because India underpriviledged, it doesn't give right to its politicians or the MNCs to short change its people's lives.

To sum we need to find following answers.

Do we really need nuclear energy?

In case of unlimitied unforseen liability would we ourselves be investing a single Rupee of ours?

Would be bying shares of a company where liability is unforseen & unlimited ?

Why the people who think that their life is worthy.... buy a personal insurance product?

If we disbelief on government; why can't their be a system of common voting by all indians (or the inhabitants of the particular area) given the choice of making their votes for a decision which is crucial to their life.....?

Why we are not ready for generating power from other sources.............?

Why still we are not trying to develop a system in which their will not be any theft of electricity?

Are their options which would define that if any accident would happen it will be very short. like operating neculear reactors in small capacities...

Will the system would allow people with reservation (the preference over cast or color) so that the less-capable person would be operating these plants........... lead to a danger......?

Basically I undertand these systems must be designed with an approach that their should not be any chance of accident. or in case any accident happend...........it should be automated that the accident would destroy the plant in such a way (Self destrutive mode) that no human life would be at cost.........?

the last but again.................

Do we really need nuclear energy..............why not go for a common voting...........why let the goverment should decide.................why not the people should decide..................let election commision give some more power.............

"You know what's the cost of an Indian life for an American MNC? 40 cents"
But this cap is result of Indian eagerness to build more reactors and is being tabled by GOI. How are MNCs at fault ?

"Do we really need nuclear energy?" YES

"why not go for a common voting...........why let the goverment should decide.................why not the people should decide..................let election commision give some more power............."

Why people still starve? Why politicins are corrupt? Why there is inequal distribution of wealth..bla bla bla.....yawwnnn
why dont you come back to Reality ?

1)I think the author is only trying to create a panic by making wrong caculations. If every body is to die, to whom the compensation will be made. Moreover if this kind of accident takes place, other neighbouring countries will also be affected. Add their population also. The amount will be much less, these neighbouring countries also have a right to cry..
2) In case this type of plant is put by any Indian Industrialist,what compensation the affected persons will get in case of an accident?
3) Further, because of the FOOD & MEDICINE ADULTERATIONS BY THE INDIAN BUSINESS CLASS IN COLLABORATION WITH THE INDIAN POLITICAL CLASS, LAKHS OF PEOPLE ARE GETTING SICK/ PARALYSED EVERY DAY AND BILLIONS ARE SPENT IN TERMS OF MEDICINES AND GENERAL WELL BEING( REPORTS ARE AVAILABLE). We hardly have any law to check this?. And how many culprits have been brought to books and and got Punished?
There is hardly any compensation to such affected people in India. In Countries like America the punishment for adulteration is so huge, and there are so many checks before and after, hardly any business person can think of adulteration.
4) Moreover,If there is such a big threat, why at all put such plants.
Regards

Thanks to the author for writing this blog and letting people know of this naked truth.
We and our 1.1 billion population means nothing developed countries or our elected leaders. Our politicians will take all their black money and flee this country at the first sign of trouble. I wonder how much MNCs paid the Congress Government people to make sure this bill is passed in its current state ? Oh well ! At-least a Gandhi offspring would not have to worry about money no more for the next 1000 years :X

If the 40c reaches the right person, we have to feel glad abt it.... :-(

dear all i am surprised by all of ur comments for n aginst but above all just think is any thing is more precious than a life of a living things can money born a new baby or good life to a children. if nothing will be left what u ll do with money. think if some thing happens what ll happen to the next generation than talk.i am not aginst of any one thought but i feel nothing is more important than a human life. if u have a power to give birth or to make human alive again than do it.
i request my indain government authorities to not indulge such kind of act if the general people will awake then u wont be able to run....
first think for common people like than act.JAI HIND