Borewells of despair : India : V Raghunathan : TOI Blogs
You are here: Home Blogs India

OUTRAGED

Borewells of despair

V Raghunathan,  07 February 2010, 07:18 PM IST

Do you know why scores of innocent children lose their lives horribly to open borewells year after year, month after month and week after week in villages and towns that go by names like Adsar, Botala Gudur, Karmadia, Katni, Madeli, Mehsana, Nimada, Raichur, Shiroor, Tehra,  and so on? Because we don’t have such borewells in places that have names like Colaba, Nariman Point or Lutyen’s Delhi where our creamy layers live or work or where their children play.  If, God forbid, one of their children were to lose their lives, borewells around the country would have been capped tight long ago, just as security in all the five stars hotels in the length and breadth of the country have been beefed up tight post 26/11.


 


That’s why notwithstanding the clockwork regularity of these tragic deaths over the years, it was only as recently as November 2009 that the Supreme Court felt ready to to ask, "Does it take much to prevent such incidents? The administration has to be a little [emphasis mine] vigilant and take care to cap all abandoned borewells in their area. Can the state governments not do this much?" 


 


A good and polite question, Your Honours.  But what if state administrations do fail year after year to show that ‘little vigilance’? Who is really ever held accountable for these deaths?  Has any senior politician or senior government functionary ever been penalized in an exemplary manner for continued criminal neglect of administration over the years? The fact is that the disempowered and disentitled poor parents and the dead children do not have the same decibel reach as the families of those who were killed, no less tragically though, in 26/11, and hence there is little exigency to address the issue. 


 


Now think about it.  We do not have sidewalks in our cities because our decision makers walk only on their treadmills.  Our decision makers don't care about the garbage ridden streets because they don't live in such streets. Our traffic systems don't work because our politicos can stop all traffic to zip through when they need to.  We will not even contemplate bicycle lanes, because our high and mighty don't cycle to work. We may be doomed to spend hours standing in the queues of the Land Registration, RTO or Passport offices before corrupt officials for routine errands, because our decision makers are the cause of that corruption, and rarely have to stand in those queues themselves. That's why borewells are of little concern to the rich and powerful, because they don't have open borewells in their vicinity.

17 Comments |  Comments are closed Rated

Related Blog Posts

 
 
 

Comments:

Sort by: Oldest | Newest | Recommended (17) | Most Discussed


Prakash says:

February 07,2010 at 10:37 PM IST

Atleast one sensible article from TOI.
Good job Mr V Raghunathan.

 

Ashok Gupta says:

February 07,2010 at 10:46 PM IST

It is not a case of rich and poor.
It is sheer negligence and corruption, because in our system of governance , no govt official is answerable/ accountable for such misdeeds. If this is treated as a crime, " CAUSING DEATH DUE TO NEGLIGENCE BY THE OPERATERS, and the officials are booked under this offence, there can be some improvement.
As i have writing through these columns that, Basic teachings are missing now a days."
Rest later

 

dips says:

February 08,2010 at 10:42 AM IST

its not about just politicians. Its also about general public and columnists who just keep blaming others politicians etc.. In a civic society majority of the members have to be active for it to function properly. They should Seek and demand the changes they want. If they don't demand the changes won't happen.. Mahatma Gandhi said 'Be the change you want'..
So if you want the footpath go, form a neighbourhood organization, make petitions, use RTI and you will see the change will happen..

If you are outraged enough, you will take action and quit blaming others.

 

Prof. Ramesh Sinha, Freelancer, ND says:

February 08,2010 at 11:04 AM IST

A very genuine concern and most sought for blog by V Raghunathan. This must come up as an eye opener for those responsible for their licadecial attitude towards the problem which has already victimised several children in rural or sub-urban areas. Had such incidents unfortunately taken place in the heart of metros, the situation would have different. Leave all aside, the authorities should initiate stringent measures for combating the mishaps or stricter punishment for responsible personnel.

 

Bobby says:

February 08,2010 at 01:04 PM IST

So True.... So so true...
But sunta kaun hai :(

 

S.V.Kamath says:

February 08,2010 at 02:48 PM IST

Politicians talk about inclusiveness, but where is it when these things are decided upon. Wish we had a KRO for politicians and re-election dependent upon its achievement.

 

sushma bhalkikar says:

February 08,2010 at 03:29 PM IST

I entirely agree with you sir. India does needs a far more sensitive and caring political and administrative system populated by equally sensitive and caring people! I can only pray that it does not remain a distant dream!!

 

satymeva says:

February 08,2010 at 04:13 PM IST

APATHY AND APATHY TO CITIZENS...THE CIVIL SERVANTS ARE ARROGANT OVERTLY AND THE POLITICIANS ARE POLITELY ARROGANT..NOT A HEALTHY TREND EVEN FOR THE LONG TERM SUSTENANCE OF POLITICAL AND THE RELATED ADMIN SYSTEMS

 

Ankit Jain says:

February 08,2010 at 04:51 PM IST

hats off to the writer...the article clearly depicts the current scenario of our political system which takes least care of the people in our small cities except during the time of election.

 

Uma Eswaran says:

February 08,2010 at 05:29 PM IST

Well written.True, I agree with you fully Raghu.You should add the manholes in the cities and small towns as well with the borewells.As year after year we hear about children and adults falling prey to the open manholes during rains and at nights.No one seems to lend an ear to such cases.

 

Nalini Eswaran says:

February 08,2010 at 07:50 PM IST

Well written Raghu Mama. This is a very apt topic in todays senario.Congratulations once again.

 

Nilofer Suleman says:

February 08,2010 at 08:27 PM IST

Trenchant and forthright as always, you have exposed the short lived election euphoria of our administrators.I completely agree that such callous attitude is only towards the less empowered, and that such insensivity is despicable!
Hopefully, candid articles, such as this one, may usher a much need change.

Nilofer Suleman

 

kris canada says:

February 09,2010 at 04:01 AM IST

Things can be changed a simple chages in the local civic rules and regulation. A person who have the signing authority and issues a permit to dig these holes should be made responsible to ensure that these holes are capped after. Now onus will fall on that person, not on anyone else. If the accident happen then make sure that person answers the court and parents.

 

SACHINDRA says:

February 09,2010 at 09:37 AM IST

Sir in cities we have open man holes, open gutter, open septic tanks, open construction sites etc where the childrens die each year.

So either villages or cities it the same as the human tendency will not change in carelessness.

 

Suki Iyer says:

February 09,2010 at 10:00 AM IST

How does one get media attention to this issue, such as in the Rathore Ruchira case? Perhaps the larger media will pick up and pursue till action only when it is personalised - a name of a specific person in the administration, and the name of a specific child, and then perhaps it can become a STORY that media may pursue? Seems like the only way things get done here is if negative attention is brought to it over a sustained period of time by all big media.

 

Vandana Sharma says:

February 10,2010 at 02:48 PM IST

Agree.We need responsible politicians and hence the need to also relook at the criteria of nominations,qualifications and credibility of leaders.We also need more responsible behaviours from al of us as citizens,I am not sure how many educated people go and cast votes.We need to build a responsible nation and a social security structure which provides at least the very basic facilities for all the taxes that we pay year on year.We should start with developing rural India first.

 

Advanced Acai says:

February 19,2010 at 01:13 AM IST

Wonderful post... Thanks for your good work!

 

Comments on this Post are now closed.

Top Rated

More
  • Day
  • |
  • Week
  • |
  • Month
  • |
  • All Time

Archives
« July 2010
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
    
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
       
Today
 
SEARCH TIMES BLOGS
 
 
ABOUT V RAGHUNATHAN More
V Raghunathan, CEO of GMR Varalakshmi Foundation of the GMR Group since 2005, is an adjunct professor at the University of Bocconi, Milan. For nearly two decades till 2001, he was professor of finance & accounting at IIM, Ahmedabad. Between 2001 and 2005, he had two successful corporate stints: president of ING Vysya Bank and managing director of GMR Industries Ltd. He has also been on numerous corporate boards and national-level committees. He has written more than 400 academic papers and popular articles, and 8 books, including the best-seller 'Games Indians Play'. He is also a columnist of long standing. Collecting old and ancient padlocks is his hobby. He has also been a cartoonist with a national daily and played chess at all-India level.
 
The views expressed in Outraged are the author´s own.
 
 
Powered by Indiatimes